Mental Health Discussion and Comment v1.1

A place to inform on mental health from the perspective of neurodiversity

A pushback on Channel 4: Dispatches

By: jonniegrieve

It’s been a difficult week for disabled/vulneraable people and people who for whatever reason are on long term sickness benefits. Maybe for some it isn’t and they are looking forward to reform that can help them back into work. Because some do. But that is not the case for everyone if comment on social media is anything to go by.

The Government White paper came out last week with rumours persisting of the Work Capabilty assessment being scrapped.  There is a focus on getting the long term sick and disabled or risk being “written off” and the NHS is being linked up at a local level with Job Centers, focusing on getting better with the singular focus on getting back to work – rather than just getting better.

And this week came a “Dispatches” documentary on Channel 4, which was a chance to highlight the real and practical challenges for those on welfare forced to look for jobs not suitable for them.

I don’t have a lot to say about the Dispatches Documentary because I could not face watching it. I knew the message that was coming.

By all accounts it misrepresents the reality of claiming disabilty benefit if you need it.  The stigma is rising. It is not decreasing. It is not wrong to use the welfare state if you need it.  These people need and deserve to be able to live with dignity no matter their personal circumstances. And if that means helping those who can be helped into work – that is a good thing.  It does not mean forcing people into a workplace environment that would do them more harm than good. That’s not good for anyone involved.  That is why it is imoportant that the welfare state and those who need it is not stigmatised.

I want to add my voice and say that it is absolutely correct that the disability claim process is distressing, demaning and absurdly difficult.  The Dispatches documentary did not advise about this.

I know first hand that the life that is often promoted about the benefits system… that it is a luxury alternatvie to the world of work… that you can live happily on £35 a year on state benefits is simply not the case.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *