Mental Health Discussion and Comment v1.1

A place to inform on mental health from the perspective of neurodiversity

Dispelling some myths about disabilities and welfare claimants

By: jonniegrieve

Welfare reform has been on my mind a lot over the last few weeks. For the last couple of years, actually and bubbling under the surface for a lot longer than that. Several years. That’s how long I’ve been a welfare claimant in some form.

But I’m not here to go over my journey on welfare in this blog. What I want to do is try to dispel some myths that have been going around in the recent conversation on Welfare. Myths that the Government and other leaders in public life have been only too happy to promote.

The fear lives in me every day. It’s in other people’s personal stories of their experiences of being on social security. It’s about people who have been badly treated by the Department for Work and Pensions. People who are forced to seek work when clearly unable to, even when they have been declared unfit for work. It makes me fear for my own ongoing journey with the DWP, especially when I won’t necessarily have the emotional and practical support that I do right now.

There’s also the fact that in the autumn the Government are going to be coming for disabled people again with more welfare reforms in the pipeline.

But that’s for the future. What I’m trying to impress on people is that the Government is letting us down by minimising the difficulties disabled people face in the welfare system. Even for those seeking employment. It’s not fun. It’s not a luxury. It’s not the good life, and it is not easy.

I hope the following section will help put that right. Here are just some myths about disabled people and my thoughts about why they are simply not true.

“Disability Claimants don’t pay tax”

In a recent speech given at the so-called “Centre for Social Justice”, the Leader of the Opposition, Kemi Badenoch, stated that she does not believe that 1 in 4 people in the UK is disabled. I looked up the stat. According to the DWP’s own figures, 16.1 million people in the UK (or 24%) are disabled.

1 in 4 people IS disabled.

We all know that not all disabilities can be seen. They’re not all found in a person using a mobility aid or a wheelchair. Some disabilities are physical but not seen. Some are physical AND seen. Some are mental. Some are neurological. In each of these cases, they face extra costs to live and work in their country simply for being a disabled person. That is why many qualify for Personal Independence Payment, but many more do not claim.

Some are capable of work. And if they work, they pay tax. If they are self-employed, they pay tax for being self-employed. And if they earn enough, their profits are taxed. Where they cannot work they need social security. And in this country we used to be able to count on the welfare state being there for us.

Disabled people can and do pay tax.

“They don’t contribute to the economy”

The perceived wisdom is that you can only contribute to the economy if you work. The way I see it is that work, if you can, is the best way to contribute. But this is not true to say it’s the only way. It is not the only way. Those who are not able to work and do receive financial support can support the economy in the same way.

The money given to social security claimants, first and foremost, goes towards helping them to make ends meet. The disability community contributes billions every year in spending power, skills, and innovation. The only difference is that disabled people who can’t work and receive social security generally do not have nearly as much as those who are in work.

But depending on their circumstances, if you give people a social security lifeline, they will pay it back into their economy through their tax and their spending.

“Benefits are easy to get”

I can speak with absolute personal experience here. It is categorically not easy to claim benefits or indeed to live in the social security system. This is especially true for disability wefare. It is meticulous, degrading, painstaking and utterly bureaucratic to get any sort of disability benefit. And I can understand why that is the case. I’m not naive to the fact that the DWP does need to know that people are claiming honestly.

But the system goes beyond that. The system is designed to catch claimants out – close routes. Claimants know that their futures are at the whim of lawmakers. And we’re seeing this as a live issue right now.

The Government is reducing the amount new claimants get in disability benefits, and it has tried to change the descriptors by which claimants qualify for PIP. This is unforgivable. People would be kicked off after reassessment through no fault of their own.

The disability benefits system is a bureaucratic nightmare. Most people face endless paperwork, assessments, delays, and rejections—just to survive. It’s important that people realise that when you’re claiming.. every bit of your life is being scrutinised, judged and assessed and even then you may face a further fight to get what you’re entitled to. As i right this I’m waiting to fight to get my case heard at tribunal. The DWP now have things written about me on file that I’d really rather they didn’t.

You do not claim disability benefits unless you really do need them. The system is very good at making sure you are an honest claimant.

“They’re faking it”

Not withstanding what I said before no system is infallable. And yet the fact remains most claimants are unjustly accused falsly claiming because their disabilities cannot be seen.

Disability isn’t always visible. Just because you can’t see it doesn’t mean it’s not real. Of course, there will always be some who will try to find a way to game the system, but in actual fact, the fraud rate for PIP and together disability benefits is vanishingly low.

Unless you have firm and actionable evidence that someone is claiming fraudulently, then disabled people don’t need your judgment and cynicism, especially not in these hard times.

“They’re lazy/workshy”

I cannot stress enough how hard it is to live with a disability. Especially when it’s one that people can’t see. Many who want to work would work if society removed the barriers they face to work. But when it comes to neurodiversity, the world just doesn’t work for us.

The Government’s recent welfare reforms are nothing more than an exercise in saving money. But the reality is that cutting disability benefits is not only immoral, but it’s tremendously difficult to do. Disability is only one strand of the welfare system. Some people have disabilities and work. Some have disabilities and can’t work; therefore don’t work.

For some people, the prospect of work is simply too distant and too tough to face. And then there are those who are able-bodied and work but receive so little income in a cost-of-living crisis that they need the Universal Credit Top-up to make ends meet.

This is all before we take into account the PIP system.

The point is that life is hard enough for disabled people as it is. Most would rather not have to claim welfare at all. But when they need it, they deserve to know that it will always be there for as long as they need it. Even if that is the rest of their life. We don’t have that assurance any more.

That is a thought I’ll leave for another day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *