Mental Health Discussion and Comment v1.1

A place to inform on mental health from the perspective of neurodiversity

I submitted a response to the Timms Review of Personal Independence Payment

By: jonniegrieve

I’ve just submitted a response to the so-called “Steven Timms Review/Consultation” about welfare reform.

Still open as of today: https://www.gov.uk/government/calls-for-evidence/timms-review-of-personal-independence-payment-call-for-evidence/timms-review-of-personal-independence-payment-call-for-evidence

I’m glad I was able to do this. I’ve been overwhelmed by the prospect and almost chickened out of doing it. I don’t pretend to be across absolutely everything about it. I’m tired. I’m worried. Other responders will be able to articulate better than me why so many disability claimants will be so worried.

But I did it. I’ve posted what I said below. Now I wait and see what happens.

What will be will be.

“I am a middle-aged white male welfare claimant. I have learning difficulties; Dyspraxia and Autism.

You will undoubtedly have many other responses that will go into greater detail on the absolute folly of your approach to welfare reform. To be absolutely frank, I am worried by many governments’ attempts to reform social security, which includes reforming PIP and the Health element of Universal Credit. I want to briefly outline my own experience.

I currently have LCW support in Universal Credit. The current Government wants to abolish this and, at best, use the *current* PIP guidelines as the gateway for that kind of support. I was previously urged to apply for PIP. After all the appeals available to me, I was not eligible. I have no doubt I will not be the only person affected like this by your proposals.

Removing PIP would remove the support I need under government plans. I do not believe the current criteria is fair, especially if you’re disregarding the criteria needed to receive support via the Work Capability Assessment. The WCA is about assessing capability for work. PIP is NOT. To merge the 2, you would need to change the entire meaning and purpose of Personal Independence Payment. These proposals CANNOT be allowed to stand for the sake of vulnerable claimants who have difficulties working or cannot work.

I do accept that Welfare Reform will be coming. But it doesn’t have to be like this. But we must not do this by arbitrarily changing assessment criteria, which badly affects people through no fault of their own. This is not an exercise in helping people into work – it is a cost-cutting measure.

We MUST listen to welfare claimants. We MUST stop demonising people who need welfare support and cannot work. This Government has been tineared to claimants in addressing these concerns, making them feel attacked and not supported.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *